Ethno-national Victimization of Ukrainian Society in the Discourse of the Scientific Elite of Ukraine: Trends and Content
pdf (Русский)

Keywords

hybrid war
consolidation
ethno-national victimization of the population of Ukraine
construct
multi-ethnicity
mono-ethnicity
Ukrainian society
scientific elite
discourse

How to Cite

Makovskaya, D., & Garas, L. (2020). Ethno-national Victimization of Ukrainian Society in the Discourse of the Scientific Elite of Ukraine: Trends and Content. Issues in Elitology, 1(4), 104-121. https://doi.org/10.46539/elit.v1i4.39

Abstract

The authors substantiate the thesis about the presence in the scientific discourse of Ukrainian researchers of ethno-national victimization of the population of Ukraine, which is based on the idea of imposing destructive scientific ideas by Russia to consolidate the Ukrainian society. The transformation and expansion of the main victimizing narratives present in the Ukrainian information field is revealed. It has been established that the main pattern of victimizing rhetoric of a part of the Ukrainian scientific community is the struggle of Ukraine against the “hybrid war” unleashed against it by the “Russian regime”, which is declared a key factor in the consolidation of Ukrainian society. In addition, the scientific discourse contains the idea of Ukrainianness in its ethnic refraction as the only way to preserve Ukrainian statehood in the face of an external threat, which contradicts the proclaimed thesis of the formation of a political rather than an ethnic nation. At the same time, the use of victimizing constructs for the formation of the concept of a mono-ethnic state is traced, and the multi-ethnic nature of Ukraine is considered as a product of Russian propaganda, introduced for the disintegration of the Ukrainian state.

https://doi.org/10.46539/elit.v1i4.39
pdf (Русский)

References

Anikin, D.A. (2017). Portraying the victim: collective trauma and sacralization of the past. In Philosophical anthropology of the victim: materials of the All-Russian conference with foreign participation. Samara, October 12-14, 2017, (pp. 152-159). Samara. Samar. humanizes. academic. (In Russian).

Basic principles and ways of forming a common identity of citizens of Ukraine. (2017). Information and analytical materials for the Round Table on April 12, 2017. Ky-iv: Razumkov Center. (In Ukrainian).

BBC. (22. 11. 2014) Ukraine commemorates Holodomor victims. Retrieved from: https://www.bbc.com/russian/international/2014/11/141122_ukraine_famine_anno. (In Russian).

Book 3 (2012). Kyiv: Critique. Retrieved from http://holodomor33.org.ua/materialy-zahodiv-iz-vshanuvannya-zhertv-holodomoru-2013. (In Ukrainian)

Dnistryansky, M.S. (2006). Ethnopolitical geography of Ukraine: problems of theory, methodology, practice. Lviv: Ivan Franko Lviv National University Publishing Center. (In Ukrainian).

Gaps and Coincidences: A Study of Narratives in the Public Consciousness of Germany, Russia and Ukraine. Expert report. (2020) Moscow: Inmedio Peace Consult; Institute of Law and Public Policy. (In Russian).

Hrynevych, L. (2011). Chronicle of collectivization and famine in Ukraine 1927–1933. Volume I: The beginning of emergency measures. The famine of 1928–1929. (In Ukrainian)

Krasivsky, O., & Pidberezhnyk, N. (2019). Ethnopolitical Challenges to the National Security of Ukraine. Scientific Notes of the Institute of Political and Ethnonational Research. IF Kuras NAS of Ukraine, (3-4), 35-49. (In Ukrainian).

Kresina, I. (2019). Ethnocultural autonomy as a political and legal institute for the pro-tection of the rights of national minorities. Scientific notes of the Institute of po-litical and ethno-national research. IF Kuras NAS of Ukraine. 2019, (3-4), 204-223.(In Ukrainian).

Losev, I. (2019). The limit of the discussion. On political-national-cultural identity. Ukrainian Week, (44), 22–23. (In Ukrainian).

Musiyezdov, O. (2020). How Ukrainians have changed over last nine years: First results of the World Values Survey. Retrieved from: https://ukrainian-studies.ca/2020/12/17/world-values-survey-in-ukraine/

Parakhonsky, B. O., & Yavorskaya G. M. (2019). Ontology of war and peace: security, strategy, meaning. Kyiv: NISD. (In Ukrainian).

Pidberezhnyk, N.P. (2018). Challenges and threats in the sphere of ethno-political rela-tions in Ukraine at the present stage. Bulletin of the National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine. Series: Public Administration, (2), 68-75. (In Ukrainian).

Portnov, A. V. (2010) Exercises with history in Ukrainian. Moscow: OGI; Polit.ru, Memorial. (In Russian).

Potapenko, J. (2015). The reception of Euromaidan in modern Ukrainian socio-cultural discourse. Scientific notes of the Institute of Political and Ethno-National Studies. IF Kuras NAS of Ukraine, (4), 4-21. (In Ukrainian).

Rafalsky, O. O. (2018). Consolidation of Ukrainian society: ethnopolitical dimension. Kyiv: Institute of Political and Ethno-National Studies. IF Kuras NAS of Ukraine. (In Ukrainian).

Rymarenko, S. (2017). Regional aspects of socio-cultural transformations in Ukraine. In Ethnopolitical context of socio-cultural transformations in modern Ukraine, (pp. 284–309). Kyiv: IPiENDim. IF Kuras NAS of Ukraine. (In Ukrainian).

Stepyko, M. T. (2011). Ukrainian identity: phenomenon and principles of formation: monograph. Kyiv: NISD. (In Ukrainian).

Stryjek, T., Konieczna-Sałamatin, J., & Zacharuk, K. (2017). Raport: Ukraińcy o historii, kulturze i stosunkach polsko-ukraińskich. Retrieved from: https://www.nck.pl/badania/projekty-badawcze/raport-ukraincy-o-historii-kulturze-i-stosunkach-polsko-ukrainskich (In Polish).

Ukrainian Peace School. (2016). Strategy for overcoming the shared and traumatic past. Short vision for Ukraine. Retrieved from: http://peace.in.ua/stratehiya-podolannya-podilenoho-itravmatychnoho-mynuloho-korotke-bachennya-dlya-ukrajiny/ (In Ukrainian).

Veleshko, E.N. (2007). The influence of victim factors on the political behavior of the Crimean Tatar repatriates. Simferopol. (In Russian).

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.